Stage 3 of 7

Valuation and strategy

This stage establishes what the property is worth today and what the bank will do with it. The strategy chosen here drives the listing price, budget, and timeline.

What happens

Appraisal at acquisition

A current appraisal supports the fair value used when the asset is booked. Regulators generally expect an appraisal or evaluation at or near the date of transfer.

Broker opinion of value

A BOV adds market texture: likely buyers, realistic pricing, and time on market. It complements but does not replace the appraisal.

As-is versus repair

Repairs make sense when they clearly add more value than they cost and do not add significant time. Most commercial REO sells as-is.

Lease-up or hold

Leasing vacant space can raise value but adds months of carrying cost and leasing risk.

Book value and list price

List price should follow the market, not the book. Pricing to avoid a loss usually extends carrying costs and produces a larger loss later.

Who does what

PartyRole in this stage
BankOrders appraisal, sets strategy, books asset
BrokerBOV, buyer profile, pricing recommendation
CounselZoning or use restriction review if needed
TitleExceptions affecting value
Property managerRepair bids and operating data

Documents needed

  • Appraisal
  • Broker opinion of value
  • Repair bids
  • Operating statement

Typical duration

2 to 6 weeks (to be confirmed)

What stretches it

  • Appraiser backlog
  • Special-use property
  • Environmental follow-up

Decisions the manager owns

  • Disposition strategy
  • Repair budget
  • Initial pricing range

Common mistakes

  • Pricing to book value
  • Starting repairs without a payback case